UPDATE: I am fully booked through March! Now accepting spring requests for April - June. Thank you so much!


For inquiries about weddings, please visit the weddings tab above for details.

Currently serving the Indianapolis area! Please note that I am legally unable to ship at this time.

2 week lead time is required for all orders. Availability is not guaranteed and a 25% "cookie emergency" fee will apply for orders placed less than two weeks before your pickup date.

Ready to order? Click here to reach out!

custom cookies - $48+

Sugar Bar classic cookies are a vanilla-almond flavor, custom decorated with royal icing. I would love to personalize a set for you! Feel free to send me inspiration photos - I'll do my best to work with you to create an arrangement that feels true to the recipient or occasion!


Minimum order size is one dozen (12). Custom cookie rates start at $48 per dozen for basic designs; adding metallics, intricate designs, additional colors, etc. will increase pricing. I will provide a custom quote based off of your request, so please be as detailed as possible if you have something specific in mind!

All cookies are packaged and labeled to preserve freshness. Gift boxes are available at an additional cost depending on your needs! 


My 9" round (or heart-shaped) chocolate chip cookie cakes are perfect for any occasion! Decorated on the edges with buttercream colors and sprinkles to match your theme, these treats will satisfy 1-8 "sweet tooths", and then some.

layered cakes - $30+

Available Flavors: Vanilla, Almond, Chocolate, Vanilla Confetti, Lemon

6" Round


Serves 8

8" Round


Serves 16

10" Round


Serves 30



per serving

sheet cakes - $40+

Available Flavors: Vanilla, Almond, Chocolate, Vanilla Confetti, Lemon

I would love to use your party invitations, event decor, or hobbies as inspiration! Feel free to send us photos or color swatches. Note that at this time I am unable to do fillings for sheet cakes. All cakes are frosted and decorated with buttercream.

10" square


Serves 12-15

9x13 sheet


Serves 16-24

12" square


Serves 24-36

split flavors

Additional $2

  • Sugar Bar Instagram
  • Sugar Bar Facebook