please note: I am currently not accepting custom orders.

Summer availability will be posted at a later date. Thank you so much!


Currently serving the Indianapolis area! Please note that I am legally unable to ship at this time.

2 week lead time is required for all orders. Availability is not guaranteed and a 25% "cookie emergency" fee will apply for orders placed less than two weeks before your pickup date.


SUGAR cookies - $48+


  • Vanilla Almond

  • Funfetti (+ $2 per dozen)

Sugar Bar classic cookies are custom decorated with soft-bite royal icing. I would love to personalize a set for you! Feel free to send me inspiration photos - I'll do my best to work with you to create an arrangement that feels true to the recipient or occasion!


Minimum order size is one dozen (12). Custom cookie rates start at $48 per dozen for basic designs; adding metallics, intricate designs, additional colors, etc. will increase pricing. I will provide a custom quote based off of your request, so please be as detailed as possible if you have something specific in mind!

All hand-crafted cookies are individually packaged to preserve freshness. Gift boxes are available at an additional cost depending on your needs! 

Screen Shot 2020-12-05 at 4.42.35 PM.png


My 9" round (or heart-shaped) chocolate chip cookie cakes are perfect for any occasion! Decorated on the edges with buttercream colors and sprinkles to match your theme, these treats will satisfy 1-8 "sweet tooths", and then some.


Standard Flavors: Vanilla, Almond, Chocolate

. .

Premium Flavors: Cookies & Cream, Funfetti, Lemon

All premium flavors are an additional $3-5 charge.

. .

Available Fillings: Raspberry, Lemon, Bavarian Cream, Caramel

cupcakes - $36+


Decorated in our signature design (shown here), or a classic swirl in colors to match your event. Minimum order one dozen, one flavor per dozen.



Signature Design



Bulk Discount


+ $3

per dozen

layered cakes - $40+

Base pricing includes a personalized message or basic design in a single color. Rates increase with additional design and color requests.

6" Round


Serves 8-10

8" Round


Serves 12-16

10" Round


Serves 18-24



per serving


sheet cakes - $50+


I would love to use your party invitations, event decor, or hobbies as inspiration! Feel free to send us photos or color swatches. Please note, I cannot do fillings for sheet cakes at this time. All cakes are frosted and decorated with buttercream.

Pricing is based on a simple design request. Rates will increase with complexity.

10" square


Serves 12-15

9x13 sheet


Serves 16-24

12" square


Serves 24-36